Here's another
“systems improvement” initiative that didn't work. From a recent paper:
Importance The
effectiveness of checklists, daily goal assessments, and clinician
prompts as quality improvement interventions in intensive care units
(ICUs) is uncertain.
Objective To
determine whether a multifaceted quality improvement intervention
reduces the mortality of critically ill adults.
Design, Setting, and
Participants This study had 2 phases. Phase 1 was an observational
study to assess baseline data on work climate, care processes, and
clinical outcomes, conducted between August 2013 and March 2014 in
118 Brazilian ICUs. Phase 2 was a cluster randomized trial conducted
between April and November 2014 with the same ICUs. The first 60
admissions of longer than 48 hours per ICU were enrolled in each
phase.
Interventions
Intensive care units were randomized to a quality improvement
intervention, including a daily checklist and goal setting during
multidisciplinary rounds with follow-up clinician prompting for 11
care processes, or to routine care.
Main Outcomes and
Measures In-hospital mortality truncated at 60 days (primary
outcome) was analyzed using a random-effects logistic regression
model, adjusted for patients’ severity and the ICU’s baseline
standardized mortality ratio. Exploratory secondary outcomes included
adherence to care processes, safety climate, and clinical events.
Results A total of
6877 patients (mean age, 59.7 years; 3218 [46.8%] women) were
enrolled in the baseline (observational) phase and 6761 (mean age,
59.6 years; 3098 [45.8%] women) in the randomized phase, with 3327
patients enrolled in ICUs (n = 59) assigned to the intervention
group and 3434 patients in ICUs (n = 59) assigned to routine
care. There was no significant difference in in-hospital mortality
between the intervention group and the usual care group, with 1096
deaths (32.9%) and 1196 deaths (34.8%), respectively (odds ratio,
1.02; 95% CI, 0.82-1.26; P = .88). Among 20 prespecified
secondary outcomes not adjusted for multiple comparisons, 6 were
significantly improved in the intervention group (use of low tidal
volumes, avoidance of heavy sedation, use of central venous
catheters, use of urinary catheters, perception of team work, and
perception of patient safety climate), whereas there were no
significant differences between the intervention group and the
control group for 14 outcomes (ICU mortality, central line–associated
bloodstream infection, ventilator-associated pneumonia, urinary tract
infection, mean ventilator-free days, mean ICU length of stay, mean
hospital length of stay, bed elevation to ≥30°, venous
thromboembolism prophylaxis, diet administration, job satisfaction,
stress reduction, perception of management, and perception of working
conditions).
Conclusions and
Relevance Among critically ill patients treated in ICUs in Brazil,
implementation of a multifaceted quality improvement intervention
with daily checklists, goal setting, and clinician prompting did not
reduce in-hospital mortality.