Saturday, July 28, 2007

Are you UpToDate dependent?

Can you make it through hospital rounds or a day in clinic without consulting UpToDate? Do you rely almost entirely on UpToDate to research topics or patient encounters, without going to primary sources? Do you feel you’d be unable to practice competently without it? Do you consider it your “peripheral brain” (translate: substitute for thought)? If you answered yes to any of these questions you may be UpToDate dependent. The habit can be darned expensive as Maria points out in a recent intueri post (h/t to Kevin M.D.).

Surveys and testimonials suggest that UpToDate dependence may be widespread. In one study, abstracted on the UpToDate website, over 90% of users thought UpToDate was “integral” to their decision making. Most usage was in association with patient encounters and 50% of usage was in the presence of the patient. Interestingly, most non-use of UpToDate was associated with lack of familiarity with the resource. Comments submitted to the website include “Can’t be without it”, “In time of need, I turn to UpToDate” and “Essential for my practice.”

Now I’m not here to criticize UpToDate. I love UpToDate and have my own personal subscription. It is a wonderful resource and, other than perhaps the cost, I find no fault with it. The problem is UpToDate dependence, which is symbolic of the larger problem of over reliance on “look up” resources. Although look up resources are essential to the practice of evidence based medicine, over reliance becomes a problem when their use supplants knowledge of basic science, acquisition of medical knowledge, background reading and clinical judgment. These essential skills and attributes help safeguard against an overly formulaic approach to patient care and result in fewer mistakes when patients do not follow the usual scripts.

The problem is symptomatic of growing attitudes which de-emphasize basic science in medical curricula and diminish the importance of medical knowledge as well as an agenda to restrict accredited CME to activities directly related to physician “behavior”.

This topic dovetails with a recent series of Med Rants posts on basic science in the medical curriculum, particularly as it relates to the USMLE Step 1 exam. Medical students sometimes complain about the basic science minutia they are forced to learn. DB, the author of the posts, tends to be in sympathy with their view, pointing out that all too often medical school basic science courses merely “teach for the test”. He suggests that the basic science content should be more focused on clinically relevant material.

I don’t know what the Step 1 exam looks like these days, or what DB has in mind for the curriculum. I suspect I would agree with his vision for medical education although I’m concerned that the de-emphasis on basic knowledge along with uncritical teaching of pseudoscience may reflect a dumbing down of medical education.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't think anybody should be dependent on a single source. If one cannot practice medicine without UpToDate, may be one should not practice at all.

There is an old proverb: beware the man of a single book (homo unius libri).

Unknown said...

Interesting post! I've included it in the Medicine 2.0 Blog Carnival at The Health Wisdom Blog.

Anonymous said...

www.clinicalevidence.com does the job for me over uptodate in a much shorter and readable format, uptodate is just far to long, in some cases 20 pages for 1 topic, I just dont have the time to read all that when I just want a quick answer at the point of care. also crucial to know thats it all "actually" based on real evidence.

Anonymous said...

buy omnicef, buy pamelor, buy paroxetine, buy paxil, buy periactin, buy phenergan, buy phentrimine, buy phosphatidylserine, buy pravachol.

buy plavix, buy prednisolone, buy prednisone, buy premarin, buy prevacid, buy prilosec, buy prinivil, buy procardia, buy prometrium, buy propecia.

buy proscar, buy protonix, buy proventil, buy provera, buy prozac, buy pulmicort, buy pyridium, buy ranitidine, buy reglan, buy relafen.

buy remeron, buy requip, buy retin-a, buy ribose, buy rimonabant, buy risperdal, buy robaxin, buy rogaine, buy sarafem, buy serevent.

buy seroquel, buy sinemet, buy singulair, buy skelaxin, buy somaonline, buy strattera, buy synthroid, buy tazorac, buy tegretol, buy tenormin.

buy tetracycline, buy tofranil, buy topamax, buy toprol, buy toradol, buy tramadol, buy trazodone, buy tribulus, buy tricor, buy trileptal.

buy triphala, buy ultracet, buy ultram, buy uroxatral, buy valtrex, buy vasotec, buy ventolin, buy vermox, buy viagra, buy viagra cialis.

buy viagra cialis levitra, buy viagra soft tabs, buy voltaren, buy vytorin, buy wellbutrin, buy xeloda, buy zanaflex, buy zantac, buy zelnorm, buy zestril.

buy zetia, buy zithromax, buy zocor, buy zoloft, buy zovirax, buy zyban, buy zyprexa, buy zyrtec, buy zyvox.

Anonymous said...

i noticed bmj has launched their new decision support tool which looks great i just asked for a trial to analyze more: bestpractice.bmj.com

Viagra Online said...

Thanks for this helpful information.

inversiones financieras said...

Like your article very much!!!
Keep it up

Search Engine Placement Marketing said...

That is very good comment you shared.Thank you so much that for you shared those things with us.I'm wishing you to carry on with your achievements.All the best.Search Engine Placement Marketing